Borders Start with Numbers: How Migration Data Create ‘Fake Illegals’ - Sciences Po Accéder directement au contenu
Article Dans Une Revue International Migration Review Année : 2024

Borders Start with Numbers: How Migration Data Create ‘Fake Illegals’

Résumé

Sudden rises in migration across the borders of the Global North have persistently attracted substantial media attention and fuelled hostility towards “irregular migrants” and “bogus refugees.” While existing qualitative studies have extensively criticised the migrant-refugee distinction, we offer unique quantitative evidence of how migration numbers and labels construct impressions of increased irregular migration while in fact creating “fake illegals.” We conduct a two-stage mixed-method analysis, demonstrating first that data on “irregular/illegal border crossings” (IBCs) published by Frontex have become an authoritative source of information on irregular migration flows cited in a corpus of mainstream news media articles. We then posit that while persecutions and violence in countries of origin may trigger migration, it is policies in destination states that determine who “is” and “isn’t” a refugee. We therefore develop a novel method to divide IBCs into those who would likely obtain asylum in 31 European destination states (“likely refugees”) and those who would not (“likely irregular migrants”) across time given asylum acceptance rates by nationality. We estimate that between 2009-2021 most border crossers labelled as “irregular/illegal” (55.4%) were actually “likely refugees,” a proportion we estimate to be 75.5% at the peak of arrivals in 2015. We thus find that sudden and large increases in border crossings concentrated in space likely concern forced rather than irregular migrants. Our constructivist approach thus unveils how migration data and categories both influence and are influenced by securitized border policies and reveals that, in this respect, borders start with numbers.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Borders-Start-with-Numbers-Manuscript-Final-with-acknowledgements-and-co-first.pdf (378.08 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origine : Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)
Licence : CC BY NC ND - Paternité - Pas d'utilisation commerciale - Pas de modification

Dates et versions

hal-04326986 , version 1 (06-12-2023)

Licence

Paternité - Pas d'utilisation commerciale - Pas de modification

Identifiants

Citer

Filip Savatic, Hélène Thiollet, Alice Mesnard, Jean-Noël Senne, Thibaut Jaulin. Borders Start with Numbers: How Migration Data Create ‘Fake Illegals’. International Migration Review, 2024, ⟨10.1177/01979183231222169⟩. ⟨hal-04326986⟩
136 Consultations
74 Téléchargements

Altmetric

Partager

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More